CEO Executive Search: How to Hire a CEO

May 2, 2023

Contact Us

In today’s competitive business landscape, identifying and recruiting the right Chief Executive Officer (CEO) for your company is more critical than ever.

A CEO can make or break an organization with their vision, leadership, and strategic decision-making. For board members and stakeholders tasked with this responsibility, the process can be overwhelming and daunting.

This guide provides a comprehensive overview of how to hire a CEO for your company, specifically the CEO executive search process, from finding potential candidates to compensation structures.

Where to Find a CEO: 5 Places to Start Looking

Finding the right CEO requires leveraging various channels:

  1. Executive Search Firms: Specialized firms with access to a global pool of executive talent, these companies offer personalized services to identify and approach potential CEO candidates.
  2. Industry Conferences and Seminars: Attending or sponsoring these events can provide opportunities to network and identify potential leaders.
  3. Internal Succession Planning: Cultivating internal talent can lead to a seamless transition. Recognizing leadership capabilities within the organization can often yield promising CEO candidates.
  4. Professional Networks: Leveraging personal and professional networks can provide introductions to qualified candidates.
  5. Industry Publications and Forums: Leading voices in industry-specific magazines or forums may signal potential CEO material.

ON Partners is a pure-play executive search firm that aims to make this process a better experience for both clients and candidates. Contact us today for help getting started.

How to Recruit a CEO

The task of recruiting a CEO is both an art and a science. It involves a comprehensive approach that looks beyond the résumé to ensure that the candidate not only has the necessary qualifications but is also a good fit for the company’s culture, values, and long-term goals.

In the age of digital transformation and ever-evolving markets, the approach to CEO recruitment should be holistic, forward-thinking, and meticulous. Every step, from outreach to onboarding, must be executed with precision to ensure a harmonious and effective leadership transition.

Once you’ve identified potential candidates, the process is just beginning. Whether through direct contact or through an executive search firm, your approach should be personal, clear, and compelling.

The CEO outreach email is a pivotal tool in the recruitment process, serving as the initial touchpoint that can either pique interest or result in a missed connection. Crafted thoughtfully, this communication should encapsulate the essence of the opportunity, while resonating with the potential candidate’s aspirations and expertise.

Download this example of a CEO Outreach Email that you can edit to fit your needs, or just read the example email below:


Example CEO Outreach Email

Dear [Candidate Name],

I hope this message finds you well. My name is [Your Name] and I represent [Company Name], a [brief company description, e.g., ‘global leader in renewable energy solutions’]. As we embark on our next chapter, we’re seeking a visionary CEO to lead our team and further our mission.

Your exemplary leadership at [Candidate’s Current/Previous Company or Role] caught our attention. We believe that with your expertise and vision, [Company Name] could achieve unparalleled growth and success.

We would be honored to discuss this unique opportunity with you further. Please let me know a convenient time for a call or meeting.

Warm regards,

[Your Name]

[Your Contact Information]

Hiring the Right CEO

Hiring the perfect CEO goes beyond skills and experience. Here are some key considerations among many that we take into account:

  1. Alignment with Company Vision: The CEO should resonate with the company’s long-term vision and mission.
  2. Cultural Fit: A CEO’s leadership style should harmonize with the company’s culture or be the catalyst for the desired cultural shift.
  3. Adaptability: In an ever-evolving business world, a CEO must be ready to pivot strategies when necessary.
  4. Track Record: Past success often indicates future performance. However, be sure to consider the context of previous roles and achievements.

To read more about our untraditional approach that has proved so successful that 97% of our executive placements are still in their positions two years later, you can take a look here.

How are CEOs Compensated?

CEO compensation packages are often multifaceted and complicated. There are many ways that CEOs we have placed in the past are compensated. Here are some factors to consider when setting CEO compensation:

  1. Base Salary: The fixed annual pay, typically benchmarked against industry standards.
  2. Bonuses: Performance-based incentives tied to specific company metrics or achievements.
  3. Equity: Stock options or shares, aligning the CEO’s success with that of the company.
  4. Benefits and Perquisites: Health benefits, retirement plans, and other perks like company cars or private jet access.
  5. Severance Packages: Outlined in the CEO’s contract, this may include compensation in the event of termination.

How Big Should a Company Be to Hire a CEO

The size of a company is not the sole determinant for hiring a CEO. 

Other factors play a critical role in this decision. For instance, the complexity of operations can dictate the need; a small tech startup with global clients might find itself in need of a CEO sooner than a local retail chain.

The growth phase of a company is also a significant consideration, with rapidly scaling companies often requiring seasoned leadership.

Furthermore, the level of owner involvement can influence the decision. If the owner is contemplating stepping back from daily operations, hiring a CEO may become a priority.

Lastly, the strategic direction of the business, such as a shift in the business strategy or plans to enter new markets, can necessitate the expertise of a CEO

So the need for a CEO doesn’t just start at “when our company reaches X employees.” It can be more complicated and something we can help you work through.

Get Help Through This Process

Hiring the right CEO is a critical task demanding rigorous due diligence. By approaching the search methodically and considering the unique needs and nuances of your company, you can identify and onboard a CEO poised to drive your organization to unprecedented success.

In the intricate dance of corporate leadership, securing the right CEO can usher in eras of innovation, growth, and success for any organization. However, the journey to find that impeccable fit can be complex and overwhelming.

If you’re seeking to streamline this process and ensure you’re matched with a top-tier leader who aligns with your company’s ethos and vision, reach out to ON Partners. As a renowned executive search firm, our expertise lies in meticulously identifying and connecting organizations with exemplary CEOs.

Let us help you find the perfect match to propel your company into its brightest future. Reach out today.

Successful CEO Placements

To see a list of ON Partners’ most recent successful placements, including CEO placements, take a look here.

About ON Partners

Since 2006, ON Partners is the only pure-play executive search firm building diverse C-level and board leadership teams. We rebuilt the institution of executive search for the way you work. Our approach includes present partners who engage with their clients from the first brief to the final decision, individually crafted solutions that are unique to each client, and an easier experience all around. Named by Forbes as one of America’s Best Executive Recruiting Firms and to the Inc. 500/5000 Lists nine times, ON Partners is consistently ranked among the top 20 retained executive search firms in the U.S.

Untraditional by Choice. Original by Design. Since 2006.

Start your journey with us today.

If you want to create a new path – ON Partners knows how to help you get there.